| |

Halloween Frozen Oreo Pudding Cake: Ice Cream Cake That Doesn’t Melt!!

This post brought to you by TruMoo. All opinions are 100% mine.

Halloween Frozen Oreo Pudding Cake with TruMoo Orange Scream! -Musthavemom.com

Halloween is coming and with that comes Halloween parties! This is the perfect Halloween Frozen Oreo Pudding Cake because it’s just like an ice cream cake that doesn’t melt! That makes it ideal to put out at your party without the worry that it will be a puddle in a few minutes time! Plus it tastes SO good!

Halloween Ice Cream Cake Ingredients

Making this cake requires a few basic ingredients including TruMoo Orange Scream milk, Cool Whip, Powdered Sugar, Cream Cheese, vanilla instant pudding and Halloween Oreos.

Halloween Frozen Oreo Pudding Cake Recipe

Begin by whipping the cream cheese and powdered sugar together in a mixing bowl and folding in the Cool Whip. Divide in half and place half the mixture in the fridge. I put half the mixture back in the empty Cool Whip bowl and stuck it in the fridge. Set aside the other half of the mixture.

Then mix the vanilla pudding according to the package instructions, substituting TruMoo Orange Scream Milk for regular milk. Whisk until soft set and then stir in the Cool Whip mixture you set aside.

How to make frozen pudding cake

Place mix into a loaf pan that has been lined with foil or parchment paper. Then top with a layer of crushed Halloween Oreo cookies. Top the cookie layer with the Cool Whip mixture you set aside in the fridge. Then top with a final layer of crushed Halloween Oreo cookies. Put in the freezer overnight.

Halloween Oreo Pudding Cake Doesn't Melt!

 Once completely frozen you may remove from the pan and slice and serve!

Halloween Oreo Orange Cream Frozen Cake

Since this frozen cake uses pudding as it’s base, it doesn’t really melt at all. It holds it’s form even as it comes to room temperature. It tastes best when frozen but it will hold well if you set it out at a party!

Halloween Frozen Oreo Orange Cream Cake

You can find TruMoo Orange Scream milk in your grocers dairy section along with the milk. TruMoo starts with fresh milk from your trusted dairy, with no artificial growth hormones and add just the right amount of sugar, and that’s what makes TruMoo A Truly Good Thing®. My kids LOVE drinking the TruMoo Orange Scream on it’s own and this frozen cake was a real treat!

Frozen Oreo Ice Cream Cake That Doesn't Melt!


 Print the recipe off below and Pin this post for later



Halloween Frozen Oreo Pudding Cake: Ice Cream Cake That Doesn't Melt!!

Sarah | Must Have Mom
Easy pudding cake recipe that doesn't melt when left out at a party!
Prep Time 20 minutes
Total Time 20 minutes
Course Dessert


  • 4 oz softened cream cheese
  • 1/4 Cup powdered sugar
  • 1 -8 oz package thawed Cool Whip
  • 1 3.4 oz pkg Instant Vanilla Pudding
  • TruMoo Orange Scream - use in place of milk called for on pudding package
  • 1 pkg Halloween Oreos crushed


  • With a mixer, beat together cream cheese and powdered sugar until fluffy. Stir in Cool Whip gently. Divide mixture in half, returning half to the empty Cool Whip container and placing in the fridge. Set aside the other half.
  • In a medium mixing bowl whip pudding and TruMoo Orange Scream together according to package directions. (Use TruMoo Orange Scream in place of milk called for in pudding directions)
  • Gently fold in Cool Whip mixture you set aside (not the one in the fridge)
  • Line a loaf pan with foil or parchment paper.
  • Pour pudding mixture into the pan.
  • Sprinkle with half of the crushed Oreos.
  • Top with Cool Whip mixture you set aside to the fridge.
  • Finally top with remaining crushed Oreos.
  • Cover and freeze overnight.


What is your favorite Halloween treat?


Similar Posts


  1. I saw you share this on Facebook and knew I had to come here so I could pin it for future use! That looks like the kind of dessert I would love! Ice cream cakes are my favorite!

  2. What a creative way using TruMoo. this cakes looks so yummy and the kids will love that its Halloween inspired. I need to find out who carries Trumoo, I didn’t see it at Walmart.

  3. Brilliant! I love that since it’s pudding it holds it’s shape and doesn’t melt. Orange scream and chocolate sound Devine together!

  4. This looks and sounds so good! With all the candy around Halloween I tend to neglect dessert, but this is a fun, festive recipe to try.

  5. That looks so delicious. I love that it doesn’t melt. I think I might have to do something like this for Thanksgiving too

  6. This looks good and even better it looks easy! We love TrooMoo and we love Oreos so this will be a hit. Thanks for posting this one!

  7. Interesting and clever idea! I’m looking forward to giving this a try. Thanks for sharing with us at the Merry Monday Link Party! Hope to see you again on Sunday night!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Recipe Rating